Here is the email I have sent ATA:
Hello! I bought an untouched ABS ATA magma kit secondhand from a 501st member in the Empire City Garrison that I'm having a couple problems with. I did a troop in full armor late September and experienced no damages, until just recently. My armor started cracking in random places for reasons I'm not quite sure of. It's really bizarre. For example, I had my left forearm armor sitting in my bin since the con ended and I opened it up today to find a decent sized crack on the inside. It wasn't like that when I took it off to put it in there. A small crack also developed on the coverstrip of my left shin. Both of these cracks I have fixed using a homemade ABS paste.
A more serious crack occurred on the right thigh, after cutting out the glued section in the back for further trimming. This could have been an error on my part, in that I should have disassembled completely before trimming. I've since rejected advice from others to order a replacement and have successfully filled in all cracks and holes.
Could it be possible that you may have unintentionally sent a brittle pull of armor out into the market? Has something like that happened before with you or anyone else? I'm not sending this email to give you grief about it, but am simply seeking answers. It could have something to do with the sudden drop in temperature and humidity that we had the past few days. I can't know for sure. You may remember me from a few weeks ago: I was the one who ordered a right shin replacement.
Looking forward to your reply. Thank you!
- Mike
I'll update this post when he replies.
In the PM discussion I had with Lance, I explained to him that ATA has always been praised as good quality armor, referencing all the ATA Centurions and EIB folks floating around on FISD. I only posted what I posted because I was frustrated; I wanted to blame the maker, rather than take into account mistakes I may have made that would have caused the cracks. I tried my best to reassure him that his armor likely won't meet the same fate as mine.
The thing is, I have no idea if the cracks are being caused by bad assembly. I put in many hours researching build threads, and trying my best to adapt them to my own build. I just don't know.