Imperial Super Commando - Gar Saxon (Rebels - Animated) CRL Discussion

[tipperaryred[CMD-DCA]]

Yes, the shin / knee plates look okay to me.  My instinct is that we should leave the wording flexible so that builders have a choice between them being permanently fixed together, or two pieces that are hinged together to allow a small amount of flexibility.

Some of the other pieces have not yet been reviewed by other staff, but I will speak with the other DCAs and ask one or two of them to review our work so far.

[beren88]

12 hours ago, tipperaryred said:

Yes, the shin / knee plates look okay to me.  My instinct is that we should leave the wording flexible so that builders have a choice between them being permanently fixed together, or two pieces that are hinged together to allow a small amount of flexibility.

Some of the other pieces have not yet been reviewed by other staff, but I will speak with the other DCAs and ask one or two of them to review our work so far.

awesome on the shins

 

Thanks for getting it all reviewed, now that shins are aprproved, i want to move on to gun, but i want to ensure the whoel armour set is good to go before i move on to gun since that will be the last piece of the set

[tipperaryred[CMD-DCA]]

On 11/12/2024 at 6:22 AM, beren88 said:

awesome on the shins

 

Thanks for getting it all reviewed, now that shins are aprproved, i want to move on to gun, but i want to ensure the whoel armour set is good to go before i move on to gun since that will be the last piece of the set

No worries.  If you look back on the first page, any items that are in green have been fully approved.  Any items in yellow are ones that have been agreed by us here, but have not yet been approved by additional DCAs.  We'll try and get those approved ASAP.

[beren88]

3 hours ago, tipperaryred said:

No worries.  If you look back on the first page, any items that are in green have been fully approved.  Any items in yellow are ones that have been agreed by us here, but have not yet been approved by additional DCAs.  We'll try and get those approved ASAP.

thanks, i forgot about the page 1 showing the good to go or whats still awaiting approval

i know i was waiting on modeling etc for a bit because i was waiting for my person to make the flight suit, it looks like she is in final stages of the pants, so i will have them in coming weeks most likely.
 

i would love if we could get approval soon so i can start printing actual armour items and actually get this armour built and approved soon after the flight suit.

To that end, here is version 1 of the rifle.  if this is approved, ia m working on a special item, i saw in the official artwork it says the rifle must attach to the thigh plate, and i am working on a way to mount the rifle to the thigh plate without it being apparent.  I have figured out a similar way for a current blaster design, so if it works, we can do it as a level two option for people

[IcyTrooper[CMD-DL]]

On 11/11/2024 at 11:44 AM, tipperaryred said:

Yes, the shin / knee plates look okay to me.  My instinct is that we should leave the wording flexible so that builders have a choice between them being permanently fixed together, or two pieces that are hinged together to allow a small amount of flexibility.

Some of the other pieces have not yet been reviewed by other staff, but I will speak with the other DCAs and ask one or two of them to review our work so far.

Which part are we still stuck on?

[beren88]

On 11/13/2024 at 6:38 AM, tipperaryred said:

No worries.  If you look back on the first page, any items that are in green have been fully approved.  Any items in yellow are ones that have been agreed by us here, but have not yet been approved by additional DCAs.  We'll try and get those approved ASAP.

any follow up on the pieces?

[tipperaryred[CMD-DCA]]

On 11/19/2024 at 3:45 AM, IcyTrooper said:

Which part are we still stuck on?

 

On 11/26/2024 at 5:19 PM, beren88 said:

any follow up on the pieces?

So sorry guys, been an extremely busy month and had a few health issues into the bargain.

So we've agree on wording for the text for all items at this point 🙂 .  It's just a second pair of eyes to go over the wording for everything from the jetpack down to make sure it's fit to submit for a new CRL.  I'll give another shout out to the other DCAs too to see if anyone is free to help out.

[IcyTrooper[CMD-DL]]

On the first page I have converted all text over to the proper coloration for where we are at. There were some changes for the UK to US English, as the LMOs will notify us of that. I think the base of the text is good for all of the items. Some of them could use some two/three-tier text, but I'll check that out so that it is reorganized to flow. The meat and potatoes of the text is good though. I'm not seeing anything that could be considered ambiguous. 

[tipperaryred[CMD-DCA]]

7 hours ago, IcyTrooper said:

On the first page I have converted all text over to the proper coloration for where we are at. There were some changes for the UK to US English, as the LMOs will notify us of that. I think the base of the text is good for all of the items. Some of them could use some two/three-tier text, but I'll check that out so that it is reorganized to flow. The meat and potatoes of the text is good though. I'm not seeing anything that could be considered ambiguous. 

Thanks a million mate.  Good to get this one step closer to the finishing line.

[beren88]

so the text is good.

 

just waiting on final say for the models?

did you look at the blaster pics i uploaded too? i didnt see any feedback on the rifle?

[tipperaryred[CMD-DCA]]

On 12/9/2024 at 10:30 PM, beren88 said:

so the text is good.

 

just waiting on final say for the models?

did you look at the blaster pics i uploaded too? i didnt see any feedback on the rifle?

Sorry yes, I did check that through and thought I replied already, but clearly not!

All looks great on the models you shared.  When painted up correctly, that should be perfect.

[IcyTrooper[CMD-DL]]

Yep those are good. We can make tweaks if we see anything that slipped through the cracks, but that usually comes when we get to the suit up phase and we are trying to make the pictures perfect.

[beren88]

that is very exciting that all the files have been given the green light.
i will start printing them today to move on to next stage of it all